Black Friday Early Access: 30% Off Final Draft Suite Shop Now
‘Ebenezer’ and How Scrooge’s Story Remains Beloved After 270+ Movie Adaptations

A version of A Christmas Carol is performed across hundreds of playhouses every year in November and December. In the Los Angeles area alone in 2026, you can see Christmas Carol Gone Wrong, Madam Scrooge: A Christmas Carol Musical, A Drunk Christmas Carol, and a classic A Christmas Carol rendition with Bryan Cranston as Scrooge. Ebenezer is the latest iteration of the timeless Dickens classic to hit movie theaters. The film stars Johnny Depp as the miserly Scrooge and is directed by Ti West, famous for his X horror Trilogy (Pearl, X and MaXXXine). With over 270 film versions of A Christmas Carol, according to IMDb, there's something about this story that keeps filmmakers wanting to come back and audiences eager to watch it. Even if audiences know the story, the spirits, Tiny Tim, and Scrooge's change of heart, they'll still watch the latest version.

What makes A Christmas Carol stand out as a piece of IP? What lessons can you take away from the success of this IP? And what does Ebenezer do differently?

How to Make 'A Christmas Carol' Original

A miserly, miserable, and mean Ebenezer Scrooge refuses to give to charity, treats his lone employee with disregard, and shuns his only living relative. But then, his long-dead colleague appears, warning him that his greedy and harsh ways will catch up to him in the afterlife. To help Scrooge realize the error of his ways, three spirits will visit him in hopes of changing his mind. Will they succeed?

Spoiler Alert: Yes. They always do.

If this is the foundation of the story, how can writers create a version that isn't the same old movie everyone has seen for over 100 years?

Who is Scrooge?

Front and center of the story is a man (or sometimes a woman) named Ebenezer Scrooge, or some variation of that character. They're the type of person who puts profits above people, doesn't believe in spending a single penny to benefit humanity, and generally doesn't like anyone.

Like the Grinch, he's not a fan of Christmas either, so all the cheer that accompanies it makes him say the famous line, "Bah, humbug," which is an expression of distaste or disapproval toward something that others tend to enjoy or celebrate. There's a solid chance a modern-day Scrooge doesn't own the Mariah Carey Christmas album, and relates more to the character of Mr. Potter over George Bailey in It's a Wonderful Life.

Who are the characters?

There are also several similar characters throughout each version of A Christmas Carol, whether or not they have the same name as in the original text. While many A Christmas Carol movies have involved Ebenezer, there are some that don't, such as Scrooged and Spirited.

  • Marley: The first words of the book are "Marley is dead." He's the inciting incident in the story, showing up at Scrooge's residence seven years after his passing to warn how he's paying for his misdeeds in the afterlife. He also shares that three spirits will visit Scrooge to encourage him to change his ways.
  • Bob Cratchit: An employee of Scrooge, he represents the struggles of the working person who must provide for their family while one of their children has a debilitating illness. In Scrooged, there was no "Bob," but rather Grace (Alfre Woodard) and Eliot (Bobcat Goldthwait) who get the ire of the Scrooge character on Christmas Eve.
  • Nephew: The only living relative of Scrooge who exudes optimism and always invites his uncle to Christmas dinner simply because he's family.
  • The Spirits: Three in total. Past is ghost-like, Present is a little chaotic and the future is a silent grim reaper.
  • Belle: Scrooge's one-and-only love who breaks off their engagement due to his greed and growing desire for wealth at the expense of others.
  • Mr. Fezziwig: The opposite of Scrooge, this was his original mentor who's larger-than-life, jolly and relishes in throwing a wild Christmas Eve party inviting everyone in his employ. Or, if it's A Muppet Christmas Carol, he becomes Fozziwig.
  • Tiny Tim: Bob's son who has a chronic illness and a weakened leg. He's a pivotal turning point in Scrooge's transition because, a) Scrooge doesn't know anything about his long-term employee and learns of this while with the Ghost of Christmas Present, and b) the Ghost of Christmas Present shoves Scrooge's previously used cruel words back in his face.

These characters, along with a few more minor ones, are the basis of the story. While they change form in some capacity through every iteration, there is a lot of similarity.

Ian McKellen and Johnny Depp in 'Ebenezer'Ian McKellen and Johnny Depp in 'Ebenezer'
Ian McKellen and Johnny Depp in 'Ebenezer'

How to tell the story?

With a story that's been told nearly 300 times in movies, it's incredibly difficult to find the angle that makes a movie-watcher interested in giving it another chance.

According to Ebenezer director Ti West in a Den of Geeks interview:

"A Christmas Carol is one of the few stories that can be remade over and over again, because the story is profound and rock solid, but the interpretation of the story is interesting every time, depending on who's doing it. The brilliance of the book is that it can handle Bill Murray doing it, it can handle the Muppets doing it, and it can handle Johnny Depp doing it, and it's intriguing to see how they do it."

Here are a few of the unique ways that A Christmas Carol has been adapted.

Scrooged (1988)

Gearing up for a live broadcast of A Christmas Carol on his network, Frank Cross (Bill Murray) is the Scrooge of the story who seems to be having a nervous breakdown as three spirits visit him throughout the day. This movie is a comedic version that changes the story while maintaining its foundation.

A Muppet Christmas Carol (1992)

Starring Michael Caine in the role of Scrooge, the story sticks fairly close to the book only with Muppets taking on many of the characters. Gonzo narrates the story as Charles Dickens alongside Rizzo the Rat and Kermit plays Bob Cratchit with Miss Piggy as his wife. It's a beloved version that hits all the notes and is great for kids.

A Christmas Carol (2009)

A faithful adaptation of the novel, Robert Zemekis, whose Polar Express had already become a holiday classic, uses the same motion-capture technology with Jim Carrey playing not only Scrooge but all ages of Scrooge and the three spirits. Being a more animated version of the tale allows the story to go bigger.

Spirited (2022)

Ryan Reynolds plays Clint, the Scrooge-like figure, but the twist is the Ghost of Christmas Present (Will Ferrell) takes on the challenge of trying to change the "unredeemable" Clint into a Christmas miracle. It's also a musical complete with song and dance routines.

How 'Ebenezer' Stands Out

"What I wanted to do is to really put the audience in Scrooge's perspective more than they typically have in the past, and I wanted to make it a more subjective journey," West said in a Den of Geeks interview. It's why the title is Ebenezer and not A Christmas Carol, for starters.

To accomplish his goals, West had to expand the other characters' stories. More depth was added to Scrooge, who has a stronger backstory, including his time at school where he is bullied, a sister who saves his life, an alcoholic father, and the fate of Fezziwig (Ian Midlane). Showing more about his family also gives him stronger emotional reasons to shun his nephew, Fred (Sam Caflin).

Tramell Tillman and Johnny Depp in 'Ebenezer'Tramell Tillman and Johnny Depp in 'Ebenezer'
Tramell Tillman and Johnny Depp in 'Ebenezer'

Ebenezer constantly sees the worst of humanity. The movie shows how an accumulation of tragedies drives Scrooge's desire to horde his wealth and believe someone is always playing an angle to get ahold of his money.

"In other adaptations, Scrooge is kind of an asshole, and then the rest of the characters are benevolent, perfect people. And it was really our goal to try to balance that out to say that there's much more of a gray area in the story," West said in an EW interview. "We want to give Scrooge logic and a good argument, so when he is making an argument about something, he's not wrong."

Ebenezer's Journey

All the successful adaptations of A Christmas Carol, whether it's on the screen, TV or stage, prove that stories aren't about the destination. They're about the journey.

We all know where Scrooge is headed, but we watch to see his journey and his transition from a miserly moneylender to a charitable and joyful person with a renewed sense of optimism, literally overnight.

The story of Ebenezer Scrooge is one of redemption. It's about seeing people for more than the surface. For instance, Bob Cratchit isn't just an employee trying to dodge work on Christmas, as Scrooge believes early on, but he has a family he loves and a child who, in spite of his illness, proclaims, "God bless us, everyone." Cratchit still toasts Scrooge for keeping him employed – something Scrooge always finds strange because, deep down, he knows what kind of a person he truly is.

Fred raises a glass to his uncle because, as miserable as Scrooge is, he's still family and Fred will always open his house to family. These moments, and many others, hit our hearts because we see Ebenezer Scrooge changing before our eyes. It's a journey we're glad to take over and over again.

Find the IP You Love

"Everybody loves IP, and I was like, 'Well, what IP do I really love?'" West said in his Den of Geeks interview.

If there's a piece of intellectual property (IP) that you enjoy, and it's in the public domain, find ways to adapt it in ways that tell the story you want to share. Even I wrote a version of A Christmas Carol because I love the story and its themes.

And if you're looking for more inspiration of adapted IP, check out these:

  • Young Frankenstein (1974) – a comedy based on Frankenstein from Mel Brooks
  • Dracula (1992) – Francis Ford Coppola's version of the famous horror novel
  • Clueless (1995) – A modern teen comedy based on Jane Austen's Emma
  • 10 Things I Hate About You (1999) – Another teen rom-com based on Shakespeare's The Taming of the Shrew
  • O Brother, Where Art Thou (2000) – The Coen Brothers' Academy Award nominated adaptation of Homer's The Odyssey